Eye contact. A smile. Friendly conversation. We all know first impressions mean a lot when we meet someone new or interview for a job. The same is true when it comes to customer interactions. How things go at the outset makes a big difference in the final outcome. Research offers intriguing insights why getting off on the right foot in the SaaS business is so important for reducing churn and building customer loyalty down the road.
Most managers, including many prominent Customer Success consultants and authors, assume that all customer interactions have equal importance. Science, however, suggests that some carry far more weight than others. While the ultimate goal may be continuous improvement at every point along the customer journey, managers should start by concentrating on the critical few areas that yield the greatest impact. And the most essential exchanges occur in the very beginning.
What starts right, stays right
Research from the wireless industry shows that first encounters matter.1 Investigators studying wireless subscribers hypothesized that customers “anchor” their satisfaction and value perceptions based on their service history, incrementally modifying their beliefs by incorporating new information after each interaction. They found that customers who had many months of positive experiences early in the relationship weighed them more heavily than they did later experiences. But if new customers had early disappointment, they became particularly vulnerable to churn.
Creating positive outcomes from the beginning yielded significant financial impact. The study found that one in four longer subscriber durations could be attributed to a series of satisfactory experiences. Doing a better job right from the start made a big difference. Simply having agents spend twenty additional minutes helping wireless customers activate and successfully use their phones cost the company $888K more each year, but the revenue increase due to churn prevention was estimated to be a whopping $4.48M. This represented gain of 2% in company profits, or an ROI of about 4:1.
Roots in biology
Neuroscience explains how anchoring works on a cognitive level. Our minds use reward prediction error (RPE) to gain new knowledge and skills because it is the fastest and most efficient learning method.2 The brain subconsciously encodes differences between how rewarding something is compared with how rewarding it was expected to be. The brain then recodes expectations after each experience, and with successive cycles, outcomes eventually match expectations. RPE therefore serves as the anchor by which the brain evaluates its next learning experience.
Learning is a mentally costly and permanent process. The brain consumes a great deal of energy building new circuitry by releasing neurotransmitters, firing millions of neurons, and modifying synaptic weightings. Given the high resource burden it places on the body, the brain is selective about what it learns, and it creates efficiencies by constructing new neural connections upon old ones. As a result, neural architecture has intrinsic latency. Once the mind learns, the underlying neural patterns are difficult to change, which explains why perceptions linger.
When circumstances are unique, however, our expectations are undefined, and our protective evolutionary biology kicks in. In these cases, RPE is very high, and the brain subconsciously reacts to the increased uncertainty. We perceive novel situations as risky, and our cave man brain releases a neurotransmitter called norepinephrine, a stress hormone that increases attention and concentration and facilitates learning. The amygdala, the part of the brain responsible for encoding and evaluating our emotional responses, is on high alert. Norepinephrine also catalyzes our autonomic “fight or flight” system, readying us for possible action. Just like our primitive ancestors, new situations put us on edge, grab our attention, and sharpen our senses. We’re ready to learn quickly because our survival may depend on it.
Learning is rarely a matter of life and death in the modern world, but our brains are conditioned to respond to new situations in much the same way. Faced with uncertainty, the brain sets the first and most impactful cognitive anchor upon which all subsequent learning is based. Our neurobiology therefore predisposes us to automatically place more importance on first impressions. Subsequent learning then reinforces our initial experiences, and in time our cumulative perceptions evolve into long-term biases. First impressions are meaningful because it’s how our brain works on a fundamental level.
Getting off on the right foot
Customer Success Managers face a challenge to make their customers’ journeys optimally productive and enjoyable from the outset. Customers’ tendency to quickly judge the value of the product and the quality of the relationship means onboarding must go smoothly. CSMs should do their homework, researching the customer and their business and reviewing account history during the sales process. During the call, the CSM should take the time to understand and respond to the customer’s cognitive state, both effectively (meeting utility needs) and affectively (meeting emotional needs). When CSMs are mindful of conversations that gratify both conscious and subconscious needs, they not only solve problems but promote the conditions that lead to stronger relationships. If action items must be addressed after the call, prompt follow-up and follow through are critical because the customer is primed to learn if the CSM can be trusted and relied upon.
As the customer learns to use their new software, they continue to refine their understanding about the nature of the relationship, too. The CSM should check in frequently in the early stages, helping the customer overcome obstacles in a friendly way. In the first few months, customers will not only come to appreciate the value of the product, they will do the same with the CSM and the company they represent, and the positive effects will stick. If the findings in the wireless industry are any guide, the financial outcomes are dramatic.
Contrary to popular belief, science shows not all interactions are created equal—first impressions really matter. Research from another industry and advances in neuroscience confirm the effects and demonstrate the financial impact. For CSMs, doing things right from the beginning sets the stage for stronger relationships and significantly lowers customer churn.
Did you enjoy this article? Subscribe to Excel-lens now and never miss another post.
Sources:
- Bolton, Ruth N. “A Dynamic Model of the Duration of the Customer’s Relationship with a Continuous Service Provider: The Role of Satisfaction.” Marketing Science, 17 (1), 1998, 45-65.
- Frank, M., Munakata, Y., Hazy, T., and O’Reilly, R. (2012). Computational Cognitive Neuroscience, Kindle Edition.